Home
Comments
If you would like to add a comment about Windermere Steamboats or the information on that page, please do so below. If you wish to make comments that are not for publication, please use my contact page.
Many Thanks.
Anthony Houghton
I reserve the right to edit or delete any comment. From time to time I may incorporate information contained in comments into my Windermere Steamboats page or other pages on this site. In such cases copyright will belong to me.
* Email addresses will not be displayed on the site, and I will not pass them on to anyone else (unless required to by law). As a spam prevention measure your IP address will be recorded. For further information, see my Privacy Policy.
Kevin Broadfoot
You mentioned that on re-reading the books (to your children) you had missed the ambiguity in the relationship between the children's mother and their 'Uncle' Captain Flint. Are you speaking of the Blackett children - Nancy and Peggy (the Amazons)? If so, in Swallows and Amazons it explains the relationship between the Amazons and Uncle Jim (Captain Flint) - he is their mother's brother. In chapter 11 (In Alliance) when the Swallows and Amazons first meet on Wild Cat Island Peggy says in response to one of Titty's questions, "He brought the parrot from Zanzibar. He's been all over the world. Mother says he was the black sheep of the family ...so he was sent to South America...Mother's his sister you know..". But I'd often wondered why the Blacketts' father was never mentioned in the books - especially as we learn that the Swallows' father is in the Navy. However on last reading S&A I noticed that the book is set in August 1929 (John and Nancy date their written alliance in chapter 10). I'm assuming that John Walker is about 11 or 12 and it mentions that Nancy is a little older. So it's entirely feasible that the Blackett's father was killed in WW1 and that is why he is never mentioned. After all there must have been rather a lot of children at that time without fathers (my grandmother was one) as a result of the war, so it may be that Ransome was accurately portraying what may have been quite common. Just a thought!
Strolling Guide
Thanks for your comments. When I say that my eldest is now 26 you will understand that I was going from memory when I wrote that piece. It was never intended to be a scholarly dissertation, but I really ought to have re-read the book before making so bold a statement. However, I think the point that I was trying to make was that far from being an Edin Blyton Famous Five 'kids run wild' romp, there is a whole back story going on amongst the adults that the children (and through them the reader) are only vaguely aware of, and in which they have no interest. And that is the beauty of his writing.